Thinking about how humans just want to be understood by each other—How could you even understand others when you yourself are in that “aimless state of ennui?” No wonder the billionaires think they’re gods. They forget how to understand humans.
This, definitely: " leveling the scales as something that might be good for the rich." To have a functional society that is not defined by wealth inequality really does benefit everyone!
The problem is that it seems to get harder to see this the more wealth you have and the longer you have it because the need to preserve and protect it is becomes determinative, in many cases. Sudden Wealth Syndrome is real (and the cottage industry around how to help the newly rich with their feelings as well as their money is amazing). But so is the money dysmorphia kicks in. But, again, yes to leveling the scales as a positive for us all!
I've waited so long for you to talk about Caleb in this newsletter and I knew this was coming when I saw that New Yorker article on Monday. Thanks for putting that in there.
It also makes me feel better that you didn't fully disparage folks (like me) who ingest both your and his content!
Have to admit I was shocked to learn that the median ‘blue collar’ salary at the time of that 1969 piece was worth 94k today. Would you ever consider doing a more data driven bird eye view look at how people’s psychology around ‘enough’ maps to purchasing power? Would love to read a narrative hypothesis of these fit together with really specific examples - just an idea!
Your point about obligations staying with us after financial independence really struck me, Katie. Being able to leave a job, care for someone or contribute without needing payment gives freedom a concrete purpose. I wonder whether “nothing is required of me” leaves out the most meaningful part: having more choice about whom and what we commit ourselves to.
The wealthy's struggles aren't fake — they're just different, and the research backs that up. Studies show money's effect on happiness plateaus well before billionaire territory, somewhere around $75,000–$105,000 in income, and separate research on ultra-wealthy households found real, elevated isolation the richer people get. None of this means a founder's "moral injury" deserves the same sympathy as someone living paycheck to paycheck — it doesn't, and the stakes aren't close. But it does mean these are real problems, just invisible to and incomparable with financial precarity, not performances staged for a Bloomberg reporter.
The IBM-versus-Nvidia comparison, meanwhile, skips over how often this exact fear has surfaced before — and how often it's been wrong. In 1900, two-thirds of American workers worked in agriculture and manufacturing; today agricultural employment is under 2%, even as output kept climbing, because the jobs didn't vanish, they moved. There's even a near-perfect modern case study: Obama's 2011 comment blaming ATMs for unemployment became a punchline because the actual data ran the opposite way — ATM count grew sixfold from the 1980s to the early 2000s, and bank teller employment didn't collapse, it modestly grew, as cheaper-to-run branches meant banks could open more of them. It's the horse-and-buggy story playing out in living memory.
None of this guarantees today's AI-driven shift follows the same script — plenty of serious economists genuinely aren't sure, since this wave hits cognitive work faster and broader than past transitions did. But measured honestly against material standards rather than 1969 nostalgia, life has improved for most people on nearly every yardstick: longer lifespans, safer transportation, cheaper goods, medical care that didn't exist fifty years ago. That's not a reason to wave off real present-day anxiety — but it is a reason to be skeptical of any argument, about struggling workers or morally injured founders alike, that treats discomfort as proof the system is failing rather than proof that change, uncomfortable as it is, has usually paid off.
I'm an illustrator, and I have to ask: did you get permission to use The New Yorker's art? And without artist credit? If not, that could get expensive.
hey! no, that's a good callout. when i link to an article that i'm talking about or discussing sometimes i'll pull in the art too but you're right, i should specifically/explicitly credit that that's where it's coming from, though even that may not be technically fair use. regardless i just updated them
Thinking about how humans just want to be understood by each other—How could you even understand others when you yourself are in that “aimless state of ennui?” No wonder the billionaires think they’re gods. They forget how to understand humans.
This, definitely: " leveling the scales as something that might be good for the rich." To have a functional society that is not defined by wealth inequality really does benefit everyone!
The problem is that it seems to get harder to see this the more wealth you have and the longer you have it because the need to preserve and protect it is becomes determinative, in many cases. Sudden Wealth Syndrome is real (and the cottage industry around how to help the newly rich with their feelings as well as their money is amazing). But so is the money dysmorphia kicks in. But, again, yes to leveling the scales as a positive for us all!
Having just watched https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God%27s_Country_(1985_film) its wild to see how much America hasn't changed
I've waited so long for you to talk about Caleb in this newsletter and I knew this was coming when I saw that New Yorker article on Monday. Thanks for putting that in there.
It also makes me feel better that you didn't fully disparage folks (like me) who ingest both your and his content!
Great essays! Love so many things about your work but you using archive.today to allow people to read important sources is just *chefs kiss*
plz drop a list of your book recs the people need them
https://www.katiegattitassin.com/p/i-read-18-books-about-wealth-class
here are some from this year!!
Reminded there is nothing new under the sun with the start of this one. 😶
Have to admit I was shocked to learn that the median ‘blue collar’ salary at the time of that 1969 piece was worth 94k today. Would you ever consider doing a more data driven bird eye view look at how people’s psychology around ‘enough’ maps to purchasing power? Would love to read a narrative hypothesis of these fit together with really specific examples - just an idea!
Your point about obligations staying with us after financial independence really struck me, Katie. Being able to leave a job, care for someone or contribute without needing payment gives freedom a concrete purpose. I wonder whether “nothing is required of me” leaves out the most meaningful part: having more choice about whom and what we commit ourselves to.
A Response to "The Troubled American"
The wealthy's struggles aren't fake — they're just different, and the research backs that up. Studies show money's effect on happiness plateaus well before billionaire territory, somewhere around $75,000–$105,000 in income, and separate research on ultra-wealthy households found real, elevated isolation the richer people get. None of this means a founder's "moral injury" deserves the same sympathy as someone living paycheck to paycheck — it doesn't, and the stakes aren't close. But it does mean these are real problems, just invisible to and incomparable with financial precarity, not performances staged for a Bloomberg reporter.
The IBM-versus-Nvidia comparison, meanwhile, skips over how often this exact fear has surfaced before — and how often it's been wrong. In 1900, two-thirds of American workers worked in agriculture and manufacturing; today agricultural employment is under 2%, even as output kept climbing, because the jobs didn't vanish, they moved. There's even a near-perfect modern case study: Obama's 2011 comment blaming ATMs for unemployment became a punchline because the actual data ran the opposite way — ATM count grew sixfold from the 1980s to the early 2000s, and bank teller employment didn't collapse, it modestly grew, as cheaper-to-run branches meant banks could open more of them. It's the horse-and-buggy story playing out in living memory.
None of this guarantees today's AI-driven shift follows the same script — plenty of serious economists genuinely aren't sure, since this wave hits cognitive work faster and broader than past transitions did. But measured honestly against material standards rather than 1969 nostalgia, life has improved for most people on nearly every yardstick: longer lifespans, safer transportation, cheaper goods, medical care that didn't exist fifty years ago. That's not a reason to wave off real present-day anxiety — but it is a reason to be skeptical of any argument, about struggling workers or morally injured founders alike, that treats discomfort as proof the system is failing rather than proof that change, uncomfortable as it is, has usually paid off.
I'm an illustrator, and I have to ask: did you get permission to use The New Yorker's art? And without artist credit? If not, that could get expensive.
hey! no, that's a good callout. when i link to an article that i'm talking about or discussing sometimes i'll pull in the art too but you're right, i should specifically/explicitly credit that that's where it's coming from, though even that may not be technically fair use. regardless i just updated them
Be safe, get permission. From the publisher and/or the artist (depending on who owns the rights). Unauthorized use can cost thousands.